For every protocol, project, company and institution, I want to ask the same questions.
Does it provide a real human benefit?
Does it work well enough to deliver that benefit?
Does it increase informed human agency?
Does it protect privacy and require meaningful consent?
Is it open to inspection, participation and adaptation?
Does it distribute power or merely relocate it?
Do the people creating value receive a fair share?
Are decisions, funding relationships, conflicts and failures visible?
Can people leave without losing their money, identity, data, audience or relationships?
Are workers, creators, educators, designers and moderators respected and compensated?
Are environmental costs measured honestly?
Does the system protect civil liberties and reduce coercion?
These #questions are not designed to reveal whether someone is a good person.
They are designed to reveal how a system behaves.
#protocol